New York Mayor Mamdani disbands divisive NYPD unit

Mayor Zohran Mamdani and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch have agreed to disband the police department’s Strategic Response Group, a specialized unit that critics say is too militaristic when it comes to handling mass protests, but others argue is essential to counterterrorism operations. Mamdani has repeatedly said he does not believe terrorist tasks and responses to First Amendment-related incidents should fall under a single unit, and he made disbanding the unit a key promise of his 2025 mayoral campaign. Under the plan unveiled Monday, those two priorities — counterterrorism and protest-related tasks — will be decoupled. Counterterrorism tasks depend on the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. Starting in the new year, the city will restructure its response to protests by creating a civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD). That group, created within the Mayor’s Office of Community Safety, will have no weapons or arrest powers, Mamdani said in Monday’s announcement. “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not receive the same police response as a terrorist threat. We are establishing a new civilian-led approach that prioritizes dialogue, participation and de-escalation,” Mamdani said in a statement. The mayor said it was part of “building a new approach to public safety.” create a First Amendment Support Team (FAST) comprised of 30 officers trained in communication and de-escalation. FAST will lead those efforts until the new civilian-led team is established. The reforms introduced Monday by the mayor and police commissioner also address First Amendment restrictions on police tactics during activities. Mamdani says officers will not be allowed to use pepper spray as a crowd control tool and that long-range acoustic devices must remain below 90 decibels. “Today we are announcing a new structure designed to solidify our counterterrorism capabilities, provide greater support to our patrol officers, and ensure we continue to respond to protests in a manner consistent with public safety and the First Amendment,” Tisch said. “These changes will make us a stronger, more effective department,” the commissioner’s statement said. According to the NYPD, the SRG “responds to citywide mobilizations, civil unrest, and major events with highly trained personnel and specialized equipment. They are also deployed in areas that require increased police presence due to increased crime or other conditions.” to crowd control during protests. In 2020, they were accused of illegally detaining more than 100 protesters during the George Floyd protests. Three years later, in 2023, a legal agreement was announced, partly as reparation linked to these arrests. That agreement now governs how and when the NYPD deploys the SRG, although Mamdani has given Tisch significant leeway when it comes to those operations. Also that year, the City Council’s Public Safety Committee held a hearing on the Strategic Response Group. Representatives from the unit did not attend “due to ongoing litigation,” the NYPD said at the time. Instead, he submitted written testimony that said, in part, that the “SRG is comprised of professional, well-vetted, and highly trained police officers.” SRG will be reassigned when the group disbands, which, according to the mayor’s order, will occur in mid-February. The move has already sparked negative reactions from police unions. “Why change it? You don’t need to change it. It’s working. It’s working,” said Detectives Endowment Association President Scott Munro. But advocates say the mayor made the right decision. “Good news for New Yorkers. Good news for public safety. Good news for the first amendment,” said Donna Lieberman of the New York Civil Liberties Union. “The numbers for civil and CCRB complaints against members of this unit were off the charts compared to the rest of the entire police department.” When asked about the issue on Friday, Mamdani said there would “absolutely” be no reduction in police response time to mass incidents. “I’ve been very clear that the focus of conversations since I’ve been in office has been how to do this in a way that keeps New Yorkers safe and protects their First Amendment rights,” the mayor added.