Fears about toxic lead dust spur battle over US Army plan to detonate bomb-making material in Iowa

Southeast Iowa residents are waiting to find out whether the U.S. military will detonate five tons of lead azide at a munitions plant after a judge ordered a temporary pause, and environmental activists and local officials expressed concern about potential health risks. A federal judge ordered the Army to stop its plan to detonate the material at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in tiny Middletown after environmental groups filed a lawsuit. The detonation, initially scheduled for Friday morning, was moved to Monday. The Army, in coordination with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, plans to destroy about 70 drums of lead azide, a compound used to detonate munitions, the military said. An explosion aims to destroy material that has become unstable. But the plan has received strong pushback from concerned Iowans, environmental advocates and politicians who fear the plume could spread toxic lead dust — unhealthy at any level and especially dangerous for children — across vast areas of rural Iowa, the Mississippi River and potentially part of western Illinois. Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds activated a state emergency operations center Friday, while officials in nearby Illinois warn residents about dust spilling into their state. Here’s what we know about the possible detonation and the legal fight. In March, the Army discovered that lead azide housed in bunkers had been degrading, according to Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle. Officials evaluating the best way to dispose of the material communicated with “stakeholders and the public in Middletown and the modeled impact area about the hazard it posed,” Telle said. The degraded state of lead azide left it “extremely unstable and sensitive to even slight friction or movement,” according to an FAQ distributed by the military to the community last month. “Packaging and transporting it poses an unacceptable risk of accidental detonation to personnel handling and transporting it, as well as to the public.” After coordinating with the EPA, experts and the community, officials “determined that a controlled detonation was the option that posed the least risk to the public in the immediate and surrounding area,” Telle said. Army officials held a community meeting Oct. 15 to share information about a possible detonation in late November, according to documents on the plant’s website. Then last Sunday the community received notice of a detonation on Friday, according to an Army press release. After the rejection, the Army rescheduled the detonation for next Monday, the “last possible moment before an expected temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material,” Telle said. Waiting too long to detonate lead azide could pose more dangers in the future, he said. The EPA’s emergency permit allows the Army to conduct the detonation between Nov. 13, 2026, and Feb. 11, 2027. Still, the issue should have been assessed 20 years ago, said Patrick O’Shaughnessy, a University of Iowa professor and environmental health expert. “Someone let it rot for so long, so now the only option is to blow it up in place because it can’t be moved,” he told CNN. “It’s unfortunate and almost hard to believe it’s happening in this country.” Iowans, local officials and environmental groups push back Officials at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant have regularly updated officials in Middletown, home to 363 people, about the planned detonation, according to Brieanna Beck, city clerk and city official, who said she had quickly shared each update on the city’s Facebook page. The city has been aware of the detonation plan for a couple of months, he told CNN in an email. The Army plant sent letters to homes potentially affected by the detonation, Beck confirmed. The governor’s office and state agencies were coordinating with EPA and military officials to “continually monitor the situation and keep local partners informed,” Reynolds said Friday. But plans and communication around the detonation have received strong pushback from environmental advocates as well as state and federal politicians in Iowa and neighboring Illinois. Josh Turek, U.S. senator-elect from Iowa, called for a delay in the detonation, saying he had “heard from many Iowans who are concerned about their health and safety due to the potential risk of lead exposure as a result of the detonation.” Rob Sand, the incoming governor, said the safety of Iowans now and in the future should be the administration’s top concern. “An unacceptable lack of communication and clarity has made Iowans understandably concerned and angry about this situation,” he said. “The public deserves to know, if this is the safest option, why other options were worse.” Parts of western Illinois, just across the Mississippi River, are included in the latest models showing possible exposure to lead dust from the explosion. Illinois health and environmental protection officials said they are monitoring the possible detonation and have sent updates to residents. Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker said Friday that he spoke with Telle and asked for more transparency about the planned detonation, now suspended. “The State is still asking you for more data on how this could affect Illinoisans and is working to keep them informed and safe,” Pritzker said. Environmental advocates sued the US EPA on Thursday over the emergency permit allowing the military to detonate lead azide, citing concerns about the potential impacts of the explosion. A federal judge on the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday ordered the military to stop detonating the lead azide. The judge’s order did not detail when the court would take action on the case, although the EPA in a court filing said it planned to file a response on Sunday, a day before the scheduled detonation. The Army, in a joint statement with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the EPA, said Friday afternoon: “The entire interagency agency is working together to ensure that the controlled detonation in Middletown, Iowa, is carried out in the safest manner possible.” “Officials have been meticulously planning for this event since March, and all agencies involved are prepared to take the most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public and disruptions are minimized,” the statement said, adding that they will keep local officials and the public informed. The cleanup requirements under the current permit are inadequate to adequately address the scope and degree of potential impacts, according to Thien Chau, senior attorney for the environmental advocacy nonprofit Earthjustice, who filed the lawsuit on behalf of the Iowa Environmental Council and the Iowa Chapter of the Sierra Club. There does not appear to be enough knowledge about how far the plume would extend, nor which bodies of water, such as the Mississippi River, and which lands would be covered in lead dust, including where people live, Chau told reporters Friday. Environmental advocates called on state leaders, including Reynolds, to take control of communication about the possible detonation. The federal government, including the military and the EPA, could not be trusted to adequately inform Iowans about the risks of the planned detonation, Michael Schmidt, general counsel for the Iowa Environmental Council, said at a news conference. “Iowans deserve a transparent, coordinated and effective response to this unprecedented event,” Schmidt said. There is no safe level of lead in the body, Dr. Sameer Vohra, director of the Illinois Department of Public Health, said in a statement. “(And) when inhaled or ingested, it can pose serious health risks.” With detonation, the hope is that if the lead azide spreads over a wider area, it won’t remain at high-level concentrations, according to O’Shaughnessy, the University of Iowa professor. “It’s kind of one of those: The solution to pollution is dilution, right?” said. There is the possibility of exposure through the air during the initial plume or through touch after it has settled, he said, adding that neither exposure is worse than the other because lead will still accumulate in the body either way. However, lead is toxic to the brain. The exposure is known to cause serious harm to children’s health, resulting in slower growth and development, as well as problems with learning, behavior, hearing and speech, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Environmental advocates also warn that the incident worsens the health of residents of Iowa, which has the second-highest cancer rate of any U.S. state and is just one of three states where the rate is increasing. The local National Weather Service office is forecasting cooler, drier temperatures early next week, with highs in the 30s to mid-40s. While wind conditions could affect how far lead particles travel, forecast winds are also expected to blow from north to south between 5 and 10 mph, CNN meteorologist Chris Dolce said.