A Radical Theory about the Universe Just Passed Some Key Tests. So… What Does that Mean?

In the 1970s, scientists largely accepted the theory that the Universe was permeated by a dark, invisible mass that prevented galaxies from drifting apart. While scientists had speculated about the existence of “Dark Matter” for years, it was the work of Vera C. Rubin that made it official. In the 1990s, deep-field observations by the venerable Hubble Space Telescope led scientists to theorize that there was a powerful cosmic force driving the expansion, what would become known as “Dark Energy.” These two theories have become part of the predominantly accepted model of the Universe, known as the Lambda Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM) model. However, alternative theories still persist, such as covariant coupling constants plus tired light (CCC+TL). Between 2025 and 2026, researchers at the University of Ottawa (go GeeGees!) tested the CCC+TL model by comparing it to a variety of important astronomical observations. The model passed these tests, challenging what we think we know about the Universe. The research was conducted by Rajendra Gupta, associate professor in uOttawa’s Department of Physics, and postdoctoral researcher Dr. Nikolaos Samaras. As they described, they tested the CCC+TL model against the predicted abundance of certain elements (hydrogen, helium, and other light elements) shortly after the Big Bang, using cosmic chronometer measurements. Their results are detailed in an article published in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. The cosmic Dark Ages refer to the first 100 billion years after the Big Bang and before the formation of the first stars and galaxies. Credit: NASA While scientists have observed considerable indirect evidence of Dark Matter and Dark Energy (DM and DE), no direct detections have been made, despite decades of research. Additionally, the ΛCDM model has faced challenges in recent years, as observations by the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) revealed an abundance of mature galaxies in the early Universe. This has led to renewed interest in alternative theories such as Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND) and CCC+TL. This latter model suggests that what is typically attributed to DM and DE could come from the evolution of fundamental constants that govern how forces and particles interact. In particular, CCC+TL changes the Einstein field equations for General Relativity (which describes gravity) and the Friedmann-Lemaître (FL) equations which describe cosmic expansion (also known as the Hubble-Lemaître Constant). Additionally, it uses the ages of galaxies to estimate how fast the Universe has expanded over time. As Gupta summarized: Most emerging models explain only a limited set of observations. A new model must not conflict with the pillars of cosmology and astrophysics, and our findings meet that challenge, including the challenge of the yet-to-be-published Cosmic Microwave Background. For their simulations, Gupta and Samaras couldn’t simply modify standard computer models; they had to develop equations and codes compatible with CCC+TL. As they describe in their paper, the model results were consistent with several important observations. Furthermore, they applied the model to all 175 galaxies in the SPARC database and found that it reproduced their rotation curves without dark matter. They also applied it to the famous Bullet Cluster, a pair of merging galaxy clusters from which Rubin obtained much of DM’s evidence. In this case, the additional gravitational effect predicted by the CCC+TL model was consistent with the cluster observations, which the researchers consider an early proof of concept. Together with Utkarsh Kumar, a postdoctoral researcher in observational cosmology at uOttawa, Gupta and Samara applied the model to observations of time dilation in supernovae. Their results are described in a separate study that is still pending review. In another study, Gupta proposes that observations attributed to DM and DE likely originated from covarying coupling constants. Comparison of age versus redshift in CCC+TL and ΛCDM models. Credit: uOttawa/Gupta et al. (2026) In the Standard Model, the Universe was only about 300 million years old when the first stars and galaxies began to form, a period known as the Cosmic Dawn. Under CCC+TL, the Universe would have been about 4.6 billion years old during this period, which would be enough time for the first galaxies observed by Webb to have formed and matured. In summary, the CCC+TL model suggests that we live in a Universe much older than 13.8 billion years, placing its age at around 26.7 billion years. Future observations will offer additional opportunities to test this new model. For example, there is the GO 3293 GLIMPSE General Observations (GO) program, or the NIRCam Gravitational Lensing and Imaging Program to investigate early galaxy formation and sources of reionization. This ultra-deep observing program will use JWST’s near-infrared camera (NIRCam) and gravitational lenses from the Abell S1063 galaxy cluster to study early galaxy formation and cosmic reionization. Said Gupta: Impossible early galaxies become predictable galaxies. We predict that galaxies exist far beyond the distances reached by the James Webb Space Telescope. Success should encourage astronomers to take the new model seriously. It is challenging to understand and apply, but we believe it extends the physics of the Universe beyond the limits of ΛCDM. Further reading: University of Ottawa