A Year On, Mark Carney of Canada Returns to Asia a Political Star

The importance of Europe to Prime Minister Mark Carney’s plan to diversify Canada’s economy and politics away from its dependence on the United States was underscored last week by his travel schedule. Carney added a stop in Dublin, joining a meeting of European leaders before the start of a previously planned trip to Asia. Last month, Carney announced that Canada is officially seeking to become the first “associate member” of the European Union. But experts say Asia offers greater economic opportunities. “Prime Minister Carney certainly seems to have a strong focus on Europe, which gives the impression that he is not looking towards Asia,” said Kazuto Suzuki, a professor at the University of Tokyo’s graduate school of public policy. “However, if Canada wants to avoid dependence on the US market and form a coalition of middle powers, cooperation with Asia is essential.” Last year, Carney was something of a curiosity at meetings of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Forum. But his January speech at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, and President Trump’s addition of energy security threats to his trade war with the world have made Carney and his energy-rich country a major draw in both. Ahead of the APEC meeting in Shenzhen, China, this week, Carney will have his second formal meeting this year with China’s leader Xi Jinping. And Carney, who likes free trade agreements as much as Trump likes tariffs, announced in Manila before the ASEAN meetings began that Canada had completed broad negotiations for a deal with the Philippines. Talks are also underway on a broader trade deal with the 11 ASEAN countries. On Saturday, Carney said that at both summits he would reiterate his call for “middle powers” to come together and present Canada as a reliable alternative to an increasingly unpredictable United States as a supplier of important products such as oil and gas. “It’s part of our strategy, absolutely, 100 percent,” Carney said at a news conference after meeting with President Ferdinand R. Marcos Jr. of the Philippines. “We are very transparent about this. It is part of our strategy to develop this dense network of connections to make us resilient, to make us more independent, to make us sovereign so that we can live our lives as we want, so that no hegemon or hyperscaler tells us what to do.” summits, Carney made a brief stop in Cambodia, where a meeting of the International Organization of La Francophonie, an association that promotes French language and culture, is being held. There, he received noticeably more applause than anyone else when he introduced himself to the leaders. However, during the APEC meeting, Carney will come down hard on superpower politics. Xi will host a meeting with President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia and Trump. Putin’s appearance, after missing last year’s APEC meeting in South Korea, stands in stark contrast to the European Political Community summit in Dublin. There, Carney and his European counterparts reaffirmed their unconditional support for Ukraine in a meeting also attended by its leader, President Volodymyr Zelensky. Carney said he would pose for a group photo of APEC leaders with Putin “out of respect for the host.” But that seems to be Carney’s limit. On Saturday he again noted that Canada would ban Russian and Belarusian teams from entering the country for the World Junior Men’s Hockey Championship at the end of the year. “Canada stands firmly behind Ukraine, firmly stands behind democracy, territorial integrity and the rule of law,” he said. “All of this puts us on the other side of Vladimir Putin’s Russia.” Canada’s relationship with China, the biggest potential market to replace trade with the United States, was sulphurous before Carney, a former governor of the Bank of Canada and the Bank of England, entered politics last year. It collapsed after China arrested two Canadians in what was widely seen in Canada as a hostage situation in retaliation for Canada’s arrest of a Chinese telecommunications executive over a U.S. extradition request. An investigation also concluded that China had attempted to interfere in Canadian politics. Polls suggest Canadians’ goodwill toward China has increased since Carney reset relations. At the same time, his views on the United States under Trump, who started a trade war and continues to suggest that Canada should be America’s 51st state, have moved decidedly in the other direction. But Carney will be limited in how far he can go with China. A poll by the non-profit Angus Reid Institute found that only 14 per cent of Canadians favor closer trade ties with China. By contrast, 58 percent of respondents want to increase trade ties with Europe. In January, after meeting Xi, Carney predicted that Chinese automakers would make substantial investments in Canada within three years. On Saturday, however, he was more cautious. While the government wants “a competitive Canadian auto sector that produces good-paying jobs and good union jobs for Canadian workers,” he said, it also wants Canadians to have access to affordable electric cars. “There are multiple variables and multiple ways to achieve those goals,” he said. “It depends in part, and above all, on where the commercial relationship with the United States is established.”