Beijing faces Russia bind amid talk of Xi-Trump-Putin summit

An unprecedented meeting between the leaders of China, Russia and the United States could take place this week on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in the Chinese technology hub of Shenzhen. China has yet to confirm that the meeting will take place. However, a Chinese Foreign Ministry official recently told reporters that Beijing was “in communication” with relevant parties. In Moscow, a Kremlin representative said “coordination” was being worked on. The clearest indication about the possible summit came from US President Donald Trump last weekend. Speaking to reporters at a Florida airport, Trump said he “believes” that one of the meetings planned for APEC will be with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping. Trump, Putin or Xi: Who really rules the world? To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 videos. Is the world ready for a ‘new Yalta’? Despite the lack of official confirmation from Beijing, Moscow or Washington, the media has already dubbed the potential trilateral summit a “new Yalta,” invoking the optics of the United States, the United Kingdom and the Soviet Union meeting at the end of World War II and deciding on the new balance of geopolitical power in the Crimean resort city. At the Yalta summit, Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill represented the three major victorious powers of World War II. Image: RIA Novosti/SNA/imago At the same time, no one seems quite sure what the three leaders would talk about if China agrees to host the trilateral APEC summit. In his brief remarks to reporters on Sunday, Trump avoided mentioning Russia’s war in Ukraine when asked about the possibility of the meeting, mentioning only “Iran” and “denuclearization” as possible talking points. The Chinese Foreign Ministry reported “no information” when asked earlier this week about the possible content of the talks. End of the campaign to isolate Putin? A three-way meeting with a photo session would be a major diplomatic victory for Russian President Putin. Since launching the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the Kremlin chief has faced years of diplomatic boycott from kyiv’s allies, most notably the United States under Trump’s predecessor, Joe Biden. Putin first raised the idea of ​​a trilateral summit last month during a call with Trump. The Wall Street Journal reported that Putin wanted the meeting to discuss ending his war in Ukraine. For the United States, the president standing shoulder to shoulder with the leaders of America’s main rivals could be a bad image, although Trump has already made a point of personally greeting both leaders with a red carpet at different times during his second term. As host, China is in an even more difficult position. While Russia and China are broadly aligned on many issues, Beijing does not want to explicitly link itself to Russia’s war in Ukraine and harm China’s efforts to present itself as a long-term force for global stability. EU fears being left out of Ukraine talks The Chinese government is also working to rebalance economic ties with the EU. European powers would likely bristle at a summit hosted by China and discussing the war in Ukraine without kyiv or Brussels present at the table. Europe seeks role in Ukraine peace talks To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video “China is clearly uneasy about the possible trilateral meeting with the United States and Russia, and although Beijing has changed its position from saying nothing to admitting that the three powers are in contact, the vagueness of these statements seems deliberate,” Alicja Bachulska, Asian policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR), told DW. “Beijing is aware of the potentially negative optics of the ‘Yalta 2.0’ framework, even if this historical comparison is inaccurate and does not reflect current geopolitical dynamics,” Bachulska said. He notes that the trilateral meeting could “trigger a further escalation in already worsening relations between China and the EU” if Ukraine is discussed without Europeans being in the room. China also has little to gain in terms of optics. Images of Xi alongside Trump, the leader of Beijing’s main rival, and Putin, Beijing’s partner in opposition to the United States, could present an uncomfortable appearance. “Even if the meeting only allowed for photographs to be taken, it could seriously erode China’s image,” Bachulska added. Beijing and Moscow stick to ‘boundless’ partnership Putin and Xi have met about 40 times since the Chinese president came to power in 2012. The two neighboring countries have grown especially close following the declaration of a “boundless” partnership agreement in early 2022. The move was announced by Xi and Putin on the sidelines of the Beijing Winter Olympics, just weeks before the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Current ties between Russia and China are deeper than they have been in decades. At the center of the axis between the two nations is a long-term strategy to contain American power while fostering an alternative global order that both Moscow and Beijing can use for their own ends. China helps Russia from the sidelines Throughout the Ukraine war, which is nearing the end of its fifth year with no solution in sight, Beijing has quietly provided Russia with a crucial market for energy exports, while also supplying it with technology and so-called “dual-use” goods. While China did not explicitly provide weapons to Russia, its exports included high-tech components that could be used for modern weapons systems such as drones. Russia needs trade with China more than ever. To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video. Officially, Beijing maintains neutrality in the Ukraine war and has refused to take responsibility for its outcome. “China is more interested in reforming global governance in a way that reflects its preferences and red lines, while preserving a collegial appearance,” Aurelio Insisa, senior analyst at the Berlin-based Mercator Institute for China Studies (MERICS), told DW. Even if China agrees to host the meeting, it will likely avoid framing it as three major powers making decisions for the rest of the world, according to Insisa. “Embracing the ‘G3’ narrative would undermine its image as a champion of the Global South and developing countries. It is also worth noting that Beijing has shown no interest in addressing the only pressing issue that could realistically be addressed in a trilateral format: nuclear disarmament,” he added. What are the real limits of the China-Russia axis? In a report released in August, the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission (USCC) described China as a “decisive facilitator” of Russia’s war in Ukraine. Beijing was “converting dependence on Moscow into lasting military, technological, economic and geopolitical advantages, while avoiding the obligations of a formal alliance,” according to the US body. However, the commission also noted that there were limits to Beijing’s strategic support and that intelligence and security concerns remain a limitation to deeper cooperation. The report emphasizes that the relationship is more of a strategic alignment than an alliance, and that deep mistrust persists in some key areas. Russian defense companies, for example, have accused Chinese companies of stealing intellectual property. Beijing, on the other hand, is concerned about Russia’s growing strategic relationship with North Korea, which has reduced Pyongyang’s dependence on China. Why a new highway bridge between Russia and North Korea worries Ukraine To view this video, please enable JavaScript and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 videos. China and Russia also differ on nuclear doctrine. While Beijing maintains a long-standing “no first use” policy, Moscow uses nuclear threats as part of its strategy. China Gains ‘Privileged Advantage’ in Ukraine War But for now, the benefits of alignment persist. MERICS analyst Insisa believes Russia-China cooperation will largely continue within this year’s framework, including Russia providing energy and potentially transferring military technology in the “few remaining areas where it retains an advantage.” “China, in turn, will continue to supply dual-use technologies, buy Russian energy, provide Moscow with some diplomatic cover and, most importantly, offer channels to circumvent Western sanctions,” he added. Notably, China will also gain a “privileged advantage” over how the battlefield in Ukraine is evolving in terms of ground warfare. “Strategic mistrust between the two sides, particularly Russia’s concerns about economic dependence on China, will continue to limit the scope of their cooperation,” Insisa said.